Glorious... a terrific show, with its likable cast! One can't help thinking, though, about all the gay men who never quite made it to middle age who would have loved to be in the audience. — Anita Gates - New York Times


The show is entertaining... campy and delightful. ‘Back in the Gay Old Day’ is a vaudeville-inspired song and dance routine performed by Michael (James Van Treuren) and Terry (Mark Baker). It's the musical highlight of the show. Van Treuren is consistently engaging. —Dan Bacalzo – TheaterMania

The cast is great…all excellent. Baker, Van Treuren and Whelan, in particular, find depth in their characters that is rare in a musical. —Christopher Byrne – Gay City News